Roots by Alex Haley

My aunt had been asking me to read this book since ages. Considering that our literary tastes are not very similar, I was apprehensive about reading it. But when she asked me for the nth time if I got a chance to read that book, I figured I better read it and be done with it before she points a gun at me and screams, ‘Read it now’.

Roots is about an African man, Kunta Kinte, who is forcefully brought to America to work as a slave. The book is about his early life in Juffure (now in Gambia), his eventual capture, his horrific travel to America and his life as a slave. The initial part where the author describes the native African life is very interesting. The book gives us a preview of the customs, beliefs of Africans and it is very intriguing. When Kinte is captured by whites to be brought to the US to work as a slave, the book takes a U-turn and the tragedy strikes. The part about Kinte’s journey from Africa to America is lengthy and horrific. The state the slaves were kept in the ship, the way they were treated, the way women were used and abused – this needs a strong heart (and gut)! Kunta, who is in denial mode initially, finds himself accepting his fate and settling down in a foreign country. He gets married and has a daughter.  The story continues about the daughter being sold to another American and what happens thereafter and this goes on for seven generations until Alex Haley, the author of this book, is born. The book is a mirror to the sufferings the African slaves were put through before they were accepted in the society as equals.

It is heart-warming to see that the author took the effort to trace down his ancestors and write a book about it, but one wonders how much of this is really true. Haley says his book is primarily a work of fiction, but also says that his ancestor is Kunta Kinte. He is said to have traveled to Jufure and talked to an elderly person there who vouched for the existence of Kunta Kinte, who was later captured and taken away. However, certain historians have challenged this claim. In fact, the elderly person from Juffure is said to have been ‘coached’ to lie about Kunta Kinte. When I finished reading the book, I was particularly impressed with Halley because he went to great lengths to unearth his ancestral lines, but when I read these allegations against his claim, I feel deceived. Why would one want to make up their ancestors? To make their book a bestseller? To gain sympathy from the world? As you can see, I am enraged!

As if these allegations were not enough to make me regret reading this book, Halley was even charged with plagiarism. Some of the portions of this book were directly picked from another book, which he denied initially, but later admitted it in writing. I wasted a part of my life, no matter how small, in reading a book which is completely unoriginal – both in content and in language.

Advertisements

10 Responses to “Roots by Alex Haley”

  1. Sonia Says:

    ur aunt…lol…reading the 1st para here. :))

    Nice narration! This book seems have a heavy and tragic parts of his life. Now I’m really wondering is it worth to read it?

  2. JoV Says:

    oh dear is it true?!!!

    I saw the movie, if you said it is such, I don’t think I’ll be reading it!

    • anaamica Says:

      I didn’t know about the fabrication and plagiarism claims until I read the wiki entry, which I always do after reading the book. I was indifferent to the book and had decided to post a neutral review, but when I read the wiki entry, I felt let down. The review is the outcome of that.

  3. ravi Says:

    Hi Anamika,

    Just one question.. from where u get all this time to read???
    m too a dot net developer and i always dreamed of reading these books… but never got any time…

    I keep purchasing them but never(almost) able to complete them. then one day i have to decide to keep them away from me in a carton.. so that i couldnt see them everyday n cry from inside that i couldnt finish them…
    but just when i do this.. i start making a new collection of books.. which gets the same fate…

    m reading your posts from some time.. n it gives a lot of motivation that this may possible…:)

    Also it makes me jealous that how someone can live in that life.. for which i have always dreamed of.. dot net blogs, travels, books,Writing..

    it feels like someone stolen my perfect dreams and made them true… while i was still dreaming about them…

    However, i bet that guitar is one thing in which i still have upper hand. (u dont play guitar? do u?plz dont say that u do). 🙂

    Anyway…ur selection of books r quite similar to mine..(as i too never liked lord of the rings, harry potter etc).
    so, thanks a lot for ur wonderful reviews.

    Regards
    Ravi

  4. Tweets that mention Roots by Alex Haley « What I have been reading… -- Topsy.com Says:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by New Book Reviews. New Book Reviews said: Roots by Alex Haley: My aunt had been asking me to read this book since ages. Considering that our … http://bit.ly/cx0NtM #books #writing […]

  5. 2010 – The year that went by « What I have been reading… Says:

    […] Disappointing Book of 2010: Roots by Alex Haley. It was highly recommended to me by many people. The book didn’t live up to the […]

  6. Margaret S. Moyer Says:

    I am in the process of watching Roots for the third time. Whether or not this was Alex Haley’s story of his family or not, I think that the perceptions we gather from the book and movie are true. All this worry about whether or not it is true just makes me more interested in the concept of slavery in the early days of America. Not see or believing that white plantation owners treated their slaves as the book states is like saying the Holocost never happened. I am a white female (or am I) whose great great Grandfather owned slaves in Pennsylvania and had 3 children by his black mistress. Those are my roots, believe it or not. This happened and is on file in the Bedford County Court House where I found something not known to me. So is the “story” Roots true, you get a yes from me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: